top of page

Before You Buy Holiday Toys: What to Ask, and Why Less Is More

Writer: Hila Bahari
Hila Bahari
Nov 11
5 min read

A friendly reminder for parents, grandparents, friends and family shopping for little ones this season.


The MORE the toy does, the LESS the child does. Yup, it's that simple!


It's the time of year that everyone is shopping for kids. We shop for our own kids, others' kids, and others shop for our kids. With sales in full force, I hope that this year we pause before we make that purchase.


Remember, we want toys that our children can manipulate, not toys that manipulate them.


5 questions to ask before you buy:

1. Does the toy do the work for the child?

"Push the button" toys do all the work for your child and don't leave room for them to do much. As I shared in my building a baby's brain post, your child's job is to discover how things work. The LESS the toy does, the MORE your child will do.


2. Is the toy overstimulating?

Flashing lights, loud sounds and too many colors can be a lot for a little one (and adults). Simple toys let your child set the pace.


3. Does the toy leave space for imagination and creativity?

These are the toys you want to surround your child with. Let them be their own little explorers and let their imagination lead the way, rather than a toy leading. This is another reason babies reach for kitchen items, remotes and shoes around the house. They are meant to explore! Pick toys that don't dictate the play, and allow your child to lead.


4. Is it good quality and material? (Non-plastic preferably)

I prefer to avoid plastic when I can, especially for babies who put everything in their mouths. My biggest one to skip is PVC (vinyl). Phthalates are chemicals often used to make plastics softer, and US law now limits several of them in children's toys to 0.1% (CPSC). Even so, I'd rather choose wood, fabric or silicone for anything that ends up in a baby's mouth. Plastic toys also tend to break more often in our house.

Natural wooden stacking stones arranged on a play surface


5. Can the toy grow with the child and be used in multiple ways?

Think long-term toys, not "one-and-done." Three kids later, these are the toys that survived every playroom purge:


  • Magnetic tiles. Seriously, the hours the kids have played with these are insane! We have about 4 packs, and I suggest adding a pack a year to keep it fun.

  • Lovevery. We started using their toys when my first was almost 2, and they have been a staple in our home for years now, through all 3 kids.

  • Books. We have many and make little libraries for the kids by rotating them often.

  • A sensory table and a triangle. Our sensory table and triangle get used so much in our home, in SO MANY ways.

  • A play couch. Our Nugget has been endless fun.

Colorful magnetic tile tower standing on a playroom floor

Why less is actually more:

The goal is not to just buy our kids "things." The goal is to foster their imagination, leave room for creativity and allow them to grow through these tools labeled "toys."


There's research behind this, too. In a 2018 study from the University of Toledo, 36 toddlers (18-30 months old) played in two setups: one with 4 toys and one with 16. With fewer toys, they played with each toy about twice as long (117 seconds on average vs. 56) and in more different ways (11 vs. 7 on average) (Dauch et al., Infant Behavior and Development, 2018). The researchers concluded that fewer toys may help toddlers focus better and play more creatively. It was a small lab study, but it matches what I see at home.


Clutter can cause children to get overstimulated and lose focus. Less is more.


Toy rotation: how we keep fewer toys feeling new

How do you cut the clutter? Create a toy rotation! Keep some toys out for your child to play with and the rest put away. Once a week or once a month, rotate the toys in your child's play area. Here are my basics (the full how-to is in my toy rotation post):


  • Everything should always have a "home."

  • For babies (about 0-8 months), rotate more often, once a week or every 2 weeks, and leave out about 5-10 toys at a time. They don't need much at all.

  • For toddlers, rotating less often is fine. Swap out toys that don't get love for ones that match their current interests. You will notice them play much longer when you follow their interests.

  • Display toys in low baskets or bins and on an open shelf so your little human can grab a basket, play and put it back. More ideas here.

  • Store the rest in clear, labeled containers by category for quick swaps.

Toddler reaching into a low toy bin on the playroom floor

Make old toys feel new again:

When the same old toys just don't cut it anymore, it's time to get creative! When my little one got bored of his puzzle, we turned each piece into a "gift" to unwrap. I'm a huge believer in creating an invitation to play, which helps a lot with independent play as well:


  • Wrap puzzle pieces (or small toys) like little gifts that they unwrap to complete the puzzle.

  • Hide small toys in a sensory bin of rice or beans for a treasure hunt. Supervise closely with little ones. More ideas in my sensory play post.

  • Present toys unassembled, like puzzle pieces in a basket next to the puzzle board or cars in a bin next to the car tracks.


Invitations to play: a car play mat, a sensory bin with trucks, a magnet board and a play kitchen

Gifts don't have to be expensive:

Who said gifts have to be expensive?! Some of our favorite Target finds were under $5, and we still use some from previous years. They're great add-ons, stocking stuffers for Christmas or Hanukkah, and travel toys.

Inexpensive kids' toys laid out as stocking stuffers and travel toys


My gift guide is available on Amazon and categorized by age.


Tag a parent, friend or relative who could find this helpful, and save this post before you shop. Happy shopping and happy holidays from my family to yours!


XOXO Hila








Sources

Note: Always check the age recommendation on each toy and supervise if a toy is not indicated for your child's age.


** Some of the links above may be affiliate links, which means MamaGuide will receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. When purchasing from these links you are supporting my work and allowing me to keep producing free content.

Comments


  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
bottom of page